Are you looking for some of the best seafood restaurants in Clay County? We are home to some incredible seafood spots, each with its own unique charm and menus, from laid-back fish camps to lively seafood shacks. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, these restaurants serve up some of the best seafood in Northeast Florida. So, where should you start your seafood adventure? Let’s dive in and check out some of our favorites!
Whitey’s Fish Camp (Fleming Island)
A local legend since 1963, Whitey’s Fish Camp is a must-visit for seafood lovers. Nestled beside a scenic waterway connected to Doctors Lake, this lively spot offers more than just great food—it’s an experience. Guests can enjoy a laid-back, waterfront setting while indulging in standout dishes like the Fish Camp Boil and Stuffed Flounder. The menu is extensive, featuring everything from classic seafood platters to hearty pastas and steaks. The Tiki Bar comes alive on weekends with live music from 4 PM to 8 PM, creating the perfect atmosphere for a fun evening by the water.
Corky Bell’s Seafood & Steaks (Fleming Island)
For a true taste of Florida seafood, head to Corky Bell’s Seafood & Steaks. Charles ‘Corky’ Bell has been serving up delicious seafood since 1979, and his namesake restaurant is a favorite among locals. The star of the menu? The Great Big Tasty Platters, which let you sample a variety of seafood, from fried to broiled to blackened. Paired with hushpuppies and classic Southern sides, a meal here is as satisfying as it gets. Whether you’re craving shrimp, scallops, or a perfectly grilled fish fillet, Corky Bell’s delivers.
Shrimp Shack Seafood Kitchen (Orange Park)
If you’re looking for a quick, delicious seafood fix, Shrimp Shack Seafood Kitchen is the place to go. Since 2010, this fast-casual spot has been serving up crowd favorites like Shrimp Tacos, the White Fish & Shrimp Combo, and the ever-popular Scallop Dinner. Their appetizers, including Crab Bites and Fried Okra, are the perfect way to kick off your meal. And don’t forget dessert—whether it’s Key Lime Pie or Pineapple Upside Down Cake, you’ll want to save room!
Cedar River Seafood (Keystone Heights)
Cedar River Seafood is an award-winning restaurant that was recently recognized as a Best Seafood spot in 2024 by Restaurant Guru. This family-friendly eatery serves up everything from oysters and crab to classic seafood combos. Each seafood dinner comes with hushpuppies and two delicious sides—choosing between options like mac ‘n cheese, mashed potatoes, or grits is the hardest part! With its welcoming atmosphere and top-notch seafood, Cedar River is a must-visit for anyone in Keystone Heights.
Two Sisters and A Deviled Crab (Orange Park)
What started as a beloved Jacksonville-area food truck has turned into a must-visit restaurant in the Orange Park Mall. Founded by sisters Jo and Kiara, Two Sisters and A Deviled Crab is known for its signature deviled crabs, a perfected childhood favorite. But that’s not all—diners also rave about the Chlobster Bites, a unique creation featuring lobster mac and cheese rolled into bite-sized balls and fried to perfection. For those who prefer something different, options like El Cubano and sides like fried green tomatoes round out the menu.
Roger That Wings & Things (Green Cove Springs)
Don’t let the name fool you—Roger That Wings & Things serves up some seriously good seafood, too! This local gem on Walnut Street offers a variety of seafood options, including Po’ Boys, Fried Fish Sandwiches, and the crowd-favorite Seafood Combo, which features clams, shrimp, oysters, scallops, swai, fries, and coleslaw. For those who love to get hands-on, the Peel & Eat Shrimp and Bucket of Oysters are excellent choices. If you’re looking for a laid-back spot with big flavors, this is it.
Crafty Crab Seafood (Orange Park)
For those who love a good seafood boil, Crafty Crab Seafood in Orange Park is a must-visit. This popular chain is known for its generous portions and flavorful seasoning options. Guests can customize their seafood boil with a variety of catches—think crab, crawfish, clams, and lobster—along with their preferred seasoning and spice level. Whether you’re dining in or taking your feast to go, Crafty Crab delivers fresh, flavorful seafood that hits the spot.
Clay County’s seafood scene is as diverse as it is delicious. Whether you’re craving a waterfront feast at Whitey’s, a casual bite at Shrimp Shack, or a seafood boil from Crafty Crab, there’s no shortage of fantastic spots to choose from. So, grab your friends and family, head to one of these incredible seafood restaurants, and enjoy a taste of Clay County’s best flavors!
